Skip to Content

Keurig Classic Vs Select: Which One Is Better?

If you are stuck between deciding on Keurig Classic vs Select we’ve got the scoop!

When it comes to choosing your ideal Keurig coffee maker instead of a traditional coffee maker, the decision might come down to comparing the Keurig Classic and Keurig Select.

Both of these Keurig machines have unique features and benefits, but there are key differences that may influence your choice depending on your preferences.

The Keurig K classic is one of the most dependable single-serve coffee makers that brews your favorite beverage in less than a minute.

With three different serving sizes, you have some flexibility in your coffee drinking habits.

However, the Keurig K select offers a few improvements over the K-classic coffee machines.

Such as a larger water reservoir of 52 oz, an additional 12-ounce cup size, and a strong button which enhances the flavor of your coffee by slowing down the brewing process.

This feature makes the Select more versatile for those who prefer a stronger brew or enjoy a larger cup of coffee.

As you weigh your options between these two popular Keurig models, consider your coffee preferences, counter space, and desired features.

By understanding the differences between the K-Classic and K-Select, you’ll be able to make an informed decision that best suits your needs and delivers that perfect cup of coffee every time.

Overview of Keurig Classic and Select

coffee maker brewing coffee in mug

Here’s the scoop on the key features and differences between the Keurig K-Classic and the Keurig K-Select coffee makers!

Keurig K-Classic

The Keurig K-Classic is a popular single-serve good quality coffee maker that accommodates Keurig K-Cup pods. 

An important feature is its water reservoir that holds 48 ounces, which is enough to brew multiple cups of coffee before needing a refill. 

The K-Classic is equipped with three brewing sizes: 6, 8, and 10 ounces. 

These are the perfect brewing sizes for those who are used to drinking 5-9 cups of coffee. 

Its dimensions are 13.3 x 9.8 x 13 inches, making it a relatively compact appliance for your countertop.

Some key features of the Keurig K-Classic include:

  • Auto-off function that powers down the machine after two hours
  • Descale indicator to help maintain the machine
  • Simple button controls for ease of use during the brew setting process

Keurig K-Select

As a mid-tier option in Keurig’s flagship line, the newer Keurig, K-Select, offers some improvements over the K-Classic. 

It comes with a 52-ounce large reservoir of water, giving you the ability to brew more cups before refilling. 

The K-Select also introduces the “Strong” button, which slows down the brewing process for a more flavorful cup of coffee, as well as a high altitude setting. 

Additionally, it includes a 12-ounce brewing size, providing more versatility in different cup sizes.

The dimensions of the K-Select are 11.6 x 9.2 x 12.5 inches, making it slightly smaller compared to the K-Classic. 

Here are some notable features of the Keurig K-Select:

  • Strong button for a bolder coffee taste
  • Accommodates a charcoal water filter, water filter handle, and water filter cartridge for improved water quality
  • Quiet Brew Technology for reduced noise during operation
  • Four brewing sizes: a 6, 8, 10, and 12 oz brew size

With these details in mind, you can make an informed decision between the two Keurig models based on your needs and preferences.

Key Features and Differences

keuirg classic coffee maker in navy blue

Water Reservoir and Filter

When it comes to the water reservoir, the Keurig K-Select has a larger one compared to the K-Classic, giving you a good reason to choose this for your coffee maker. 

The K-Select features 52oz removable water reservoirs, while the K-Classic has 48oz water reservoirs. 

This means you can brew more cups of coffee with the K-Select before having to refill the water reservoir. 

Both units have removable reservoirs, facilitating easier clean-up.

Brew Sizes and Cup Sizes

The K-Select offers four different brew sizes, namely 6, 8, 10, and 12 oz cups. 

In comparison, the K-Classic comes with three serving sizes. 

This gives you more options and flexibility with the K-Select. 

Furthermore, the K-Select introduces a “strong” button feature, enhancing the flavor of your coffee by slowing down the brewing process by 30 seconds.

Temperature Control

When it comes to temperature control, neither the K-Select nor the K-Classic has this feature. 

If you require temperature control, you should consider upgrading to the Keurig K-Elite.

Auto-Off Feature

Both the K-Select and K-Classic come with an auto-off feature. 

This helps save energy by automatically turning off the brewer when it’s not in use for a specified amount of time.

Noise and Energy Consumption

While both models operate with similar energy consumption levels, the K-Select boasts a quieter brewing experience. 

This can be particularly beneficial if you’re sensitive to noise or live in a shared living space.

Color Options

The K-Select offers a variety of color options, allowing you to choose one that best suits your kitchen’s decor or aesthetic preferences. 

The K-Classic model, on the other hand, has fewer color options available. 

So, if you’re looking for more customization, the K-Select might be the better option for you.

Performance and Brew Quality

keurig select coffee maker in black

Speed and Brew Strength

When comparing the Keurig K-Select and the K-Classic coffee makers, both models have a similar time frame when it comes to heating up and brewing. 

They typically take 3 to 4 minutes for the initial heat-up and around 40 seconds to brew an 8-ounce cup of coffee. 

While there may not be a significant difference in speed, the K-Select offers a crucial feature called the Strong Brew, allowing you to increase the strength and boldness of your coffee.

Flavor and Coffee Quality

different styles and colors of coffee makers

As a coffee enthusiast, the flavor and quality of your brew are important factors. 

The K-Classic has seen improvements in brew quality compared to older models, but it lacks some features found in other current Keurig models like the K-Select. 

The K-Select brings more customizable benefits, enabling you to choose from four different serving sizes compared to the K-Classic’s three options. 

This additional flexibility allows you to personalize your coffee experience to suit your preferences.

Iced Coffee and Other Beverages

Keurig coffee makers are versatile machines that can brew a variety of beverages beyond hot coffee. 

With the use of Keurig pods such as the K-Cup pods, you can easily prepare iced coffee, tea, hot cocoa, and more.

Both the K-Select and K-Classic are compatible with a wide array of K-Cup pods, giving you access to many different flavors and types of beverages.

Here are a few key points regarding iced coffee and other beverages:

  • Both K-Select and K-Classic work with the standard K-Cup pods designed for iced coffee.
  • Tea, hot cocoa, and other specialty beverage K-Cup pods are also compatible with both models.

Though the K-Select and K-Classic have many similarities, aspects such as brew strength customization and serving size options make the K-Select a more versatile machine in terms of performance and brew quality.

Design and Dimensions

coffee maker keurig slsect

Compact and User-Friendly

Keurig K-Select and K-Classic coffee makers are designed to be compact and user-friendly. 

The dimensions of the K-Select are 11.6 x 9.2 x 12.5 inches, while the dimensions of the K-Classic are 13.3 x 9.8 x 13 inches. 

This slight difference in size means that both models easily fit on your countertop without taking up too much space. 

Their design is sleek, with the K-Select available in a variety of colors, such as Navy, Matte Black, Matte White, and Vintage Red.

Drip Trays and Water Tank

The Keurig K-Select, along with the K-Classic, has a removable drip tray, making cleaning easy. 

Additionally, these trays also allow you to use taller cups by creating more space when removed. 

The K-Select has an advantage in terms of its water tank capacity – it can accommodate a slightly larger reservoir, allowing you to brew more cups before needing to refill.

Control Panel and Interface

classic keurig coffee maker in black

The control panels on both the K-Select and K-Classic are designed to be simple and intuitive, allowing you to quickly and easily brew your favorite coffee. 

One main difference between the two models is the “Strong” button on the K-Select, which slows the brewing process by 30 seconds, resulting in a more flavorful coffee. 

This feature is not available on the K-Classic, making the K-Select a more versatile option in terms of brewing strength.

The Keurig K-Select and K-Classic share some similarities in their designs, but also have a few differences in dimensions and features, such as the strong button and water tank capacity. 

The choice between these two models will ultimately depend on your personal preferences and needs.

Alternatives to Classic and Select

woman making coffee with her coffee maker

Keurig K-Mini and K-Slim

If you’re considering the Keurig Classic or Select but want something more compact, the Keurig K-Mini and K-Slim could be perfect choices. 

These models are designed for small spaces and have a sleek, space-saving design. 

The K-Mini has a single-cup water reservoir, so you’ll need to fill it with fresh water every time you want to brew a cup. 

The K-Slim, on the other hand, has a 46-ounce water reservoir, allowing you to brew multiple cups without constantly refilling.

Both the K-Mini and K-Slim offer flexibility in cup sizes, with the ability to brew 6 to 12-ounce cups. 

They also have removable drip trays, making it easy to accommodate a taller travel mug. 

These models don’t have the strong brew button option like the K-Select, but they still deliver great-tasting coffee in a compact form factor.

Some additional popular choices to take a closer look at are the K-supreme plus, K-mini plus, K-duo plus, Keurig K-cafe, and Keurig my K-cup.

Keurig K-Elite and K-Cafe

For those who want more advanced features and additional brewing options, the Keurig K-Elite and K-Cafe are excellent alternatives to the Classic and Select. 

The K-Elite boasts a larger water tank than the K-Select, an added 4-ounce cup size, and the ability to adjust the temperature of your brew. 

It also includes the strong brew button, ensuring that you can brew coffee to your preferred strength.

The K-Cafe, on the other hand, is a versatile option for coffee lovers who enjoy different types of beverages. 

It not only brews standard coffee but also includes a built-in milk frother that allows you to make lattes and cappuccinos as well. 

The K-Cafe can brew 6-12 ounce cups, similar to the K-Mini and K-Slim, and has a strong brew button like the K-Elite.

While considering these alternatives, assess your needs and preferences, and choose the Keurig model that best suits your lifestyle and coffee habits.

User Experience and Convenience

grey keurig select coffee maker

Ease of Use

Keurig coffee makers are designed for convenience, and both the K-Select and K-Classic models make brewing your favorite cup of coffee simple. 

With a one-touch brewing system, you can choose from available serving sizes and easily start the brewing process. 

The K-Select introduces a strong button, enabling you to enjoy a more flavorful cup by slowing down the brewing time.

Cleaning and Dishwasher-Safe Parts

Maintaining your Keurig coffee maker is important to ensure it continues to function efficiently. 

Both the K-Select and K-Classic models come with removable parts to make cleaning stress-free.

By regularly cleaning your coffee maker, you’re also contributing to the longevity and overall performance of the device. 

Always check the manufacturer’s guidelines to confirm which parts are dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning.

Warranty and Support

A solid warranty can give you peace of mind when purchasing any appliance. 

Fortunately, Keurig offers a one-year limited warranty for both the K-Select and K-Classic models. 

This warranty covers defects in materials and workmanship, ensuring that you’re protected against any manufacturing faults. 

In case you need assistance, Keurig provides excellent customer support to help you with any questions, troubleshooting, or maintenance concerns.

By considering these factors, you can choose the right Keurig coffee maker that best suits your needs and preferences. 

With easy-to-use features, convenient cleaning options, and reliable warranty and support, you’ll enjoy a hassle-free coffee-brewing experience.

Final Thoughts

coffee maker on top of counter

As a coffee lover, selecting the right Keurig coffee maker can be challenging. 

However, when it comes to choosing between the Keurig K-Select vs K-Classic, the differences become more apparent.

  1. Brew Sizes and Water Capacity: The K-Select offers four different serving sizes while the K-Classic has three. Additionally, the K-Select has a larger 52 oz water reservoir, compared to the K-Classic’s 48oz reservoir. This means you can enjoy more cups of coffee before needing a refill.
  2. Strong Brew Option: The K-Select features a strong button that slows down the brewing process for a more flavorful cup of coffee. This feature is not available in the K-Classic.
  3. Price Range: The K-Select is priced more affordably than the K-Elite while still offering features like brew size options, strength control, and a larger water reservoir.

Each model suits different preferences when it comes to convenience, customization, and value. 

Consider how these benefits align with your coffee-making priorities. 

In the end, you and other coffee lovers can find satisfaction in both the K-Select and K-Classic as reliable, quality options for the best Keurig coffee makers.

keurig classic vs select Pinterest image

Get the scoop on more like this: