Skip to Content

Can You Put A Plate In A Toaster Oven: Tips To Use

Toaster ovens are versatile kitchen gadgets that can do much more than toasting and reheating. Here’s the scoop on can you put a plate in a toaster oven!

toaster oven on kitchen countertop

Whether making a piece of toast, or cooking frozen french fries, the toaster oven has got you covered. However, you might be wondering if you can safely put a plate in a toaster oven.

Well, it largely depends on the type of plate and its type of material. 

Although, the short answer is yes. You can put a plate in a toaster oven to warm food, but it’s vital to ensure that the plate is made from a material deemed safe for oven use.

A toaster oven manual that comes with each specific toaster oven will help to identify proper materials. As well as what is to be used inside of the toaster. 

Another great resource is a toaster oven manufacturer or plate manufacturer.

They will typically provide information on whether specific plates are oven-safe. This could be found in the user manual or marked on the bottom of the plate.

Just remember to choose plates with an oven-safe symbol to avoid any potential hazards.

When putting a plate in a toaster oven, consider its positioning and close proximity to avoid touching the heating elements.

The best way to use glass or ceramic plates is to place them on the wire rack in the middle of the toaster oven. It is a great thing to do in order to ensure safety.

Materials like plastic, on the other hand, should be avoided, as they might burn when exposed to heat. Remember to always keep an eye out for the oven-safe symbol on the bottom of the dish.

Can You Put a Plate in a Toaster Oven?

close up of buttons on a toaster oven

Oven-Safe Materials

Yes, you can put a plate in a toaster oven if it is made of oven-safe materials commonly used for a standard oven.

Oven-safe materials work for more than just a regular oven.

Although, even with the best toaster ovens, it is always a good idea to choose plates that have an oven-safe symbol in their user manual or on the plate itself.

Different options for oven-safe materials include:

  • Glass: Make sure it’s labeled as oven-safe or heat-resistant glass, like Pyrex.
  • Ceramic: Ensure the ceramic plate is labeled as oven-safe.
  • Metal: Stainless steel, cast iron, or aluminum plates that are oven-safe.

When using oven-safe plates, remember to follow the guidelines mentioned in the plates’ user manual. This will prevent any damage and ensure safe usage.

Most materials used in a conventional oven can be safely used in a toaster oven, so it is important to look out for the oven-safe symbol. 

Unsafe Materials

Some materials or types of bakeware should never be placed in a toaster oven, as they can cause damage, release harmful fumes, or even start a fire.

Your toaster oven may not always offer specific instructions within the manual, therefore it is important to keep an eye out. Various products that are unsafe include:

  • Plastic: Plastic plates can melt or release toxic fumes when exposed to heat.
  • Paper: Paper plates can easily catch fire if they touch the heating element or get too close.
  • Styrofoam: Similar to plastic, it can melt and release harmful fumes.
  • Non-heat resistant glass: It can shatter or crack due to the temperature changes.

Even the best toasters from the best place, whether it be hamilton beach or any other high end brand, will still not react well to these materials. 

Safety Precautions

To ensure your safety and that of your toaster oven, it is essential to follow these precautions:

  1. Check the plate: Make sure your plate is made of heat-safe material and displays an oven-safe symbol before placing it in the toaster oven.
  2. Monitor the temperature: Keep an eye on the toaster oven temperature to avoid overheating or burning the plate.
  3. Use oven mitts: Always use oven mitts to handle hot plates and avoid burns.

You can put a plate in a toaster oven if it is made of oven-safe materials. Keep track of the temperature limit on your toaster oven.

Be cautious of the materials and follow the necessary safety precautions to ensure whatever you are using is toaster oven-safe.

All kitchen appliances have their own requirements so it is important to ensure proper safety precautions.

Reading the manual or consumer reports can help you ensure whether it is oven-safe or not. 

Types of Plates and Toaster Oven Compatibility

toaster oven with food inside

Ceramic Plates

Ceramic plates and ceramic dinnerware can potentially be used in a toaster oven if they are designed for that purpose.

It’s crucial to ensure that the plate is labeled as oven-safe or a heat-resistant material before placing it in the toaster oven.

The same general guidelines apply to stoneware and earthenware plates that have the oven-safe label.

Keep in mind that the heat resistance level might differ based on the material composition and the manufacturer’s recommendations.

Carefully examine your ceramic plates, ceramic dishes, or coffee mugs for any oven-safe indication or refer to the manufacturer’s instructions.

Glass Plates

Similar to ceramic plates, glass dishes or glass bakeware can be put in a toaster oven as long as they are labeled as toaster oven safe.

However, it’s essential to note that most types of glass plates are not suitable for toaster oven use.

When using glass plates in a toaster oven, opt for heat-resistant glassware specifically designed for oven use.

Avoid using standard glass plates as they could crack or shatter due to drastic temperature changes.

Metal Plates

Metal plates or stainless steel plates are a safe option for putting in a toaster oven, provided they are made from heat-resistant materials like stainless steel.

Aluminum plates are also frequently used in cooking and can withstand a toaster oven’s heat.

While using metal plates, or a baking sheet ensure the plate material does not produce toxic fumes when exposed to high temperatures.

Moreover, be cautious of handling hot metal plates to prevent burns.

Microwave-Safe Plates

Microwave-safe plates are generally made of materials that can withstand microwave radiation exposure and hot air.

These materials work well in the microwave or a microwave oven.

However, it’s important to remember that being microwave-safe does not guarantee oven-safe compatibility.

Before placing a microwave-safe plate in your toaster oven, check for additional labels or information on the plate’s heat resistance to confirm its suitability for toaster oven usage.

Potential Risks and Dangers

stainless steel toaster oven

Thermal Shock

Be cautious when putting a plate in a toaster oven, as thermal shock is a potential risk.

This occurs when a significant temperature change causes materials, such as ceramics or glass, to contract or expand rapidly. 

Extreme temperatures and changes in temperature can lead to cracks, breaks, or shattering of your plate.

To avoid this, make sure that your plate is labeled as toaster oven safe and that you’re not exposing the plate to extreme temperature differences. Each toaster oven’s heating element is different. 

Heat Damage

Heat damage is another potential issue when using plates in a toaster oven.

Some materials, like plastic, are not suitable for high temperatures from the heat source and may melt or warp when exposed to heat.

 Even a little bit of time in the toaster oven can be enough for these incidents to occur. Exposure to high heat can also be a fire hazard. Sometimes a lower temperature can lead to better results. 

Always check for an oven-safe symbol in the user manual or on the back of the plate before using it in a toaster oven.

It’s best to use ceramic plates or materials specifically designed to withstand high temperatures to prevent heat damage.

Fire Hazards

Remember that fire hazards are a possibility when using a toaster oven or convection oven, especially with plates containing flammable materials or when cooking fatty or greasy foods.

To minimize the risk of a fire, avoid using plates made of flammable materials and be cautious with fatty or greasy foods that can drip onto the heating elements. 

Always keep an eye on the toaster oven while in use and make sure to clean it regularly to prevent the buildup of grease and debris.

It is always a good idea to have a fire extinguisher in the kitchen to be extra cautious. 

Using Alternative Cookware in a Toaster Oven

black and silver toaster oven on a countertop

Aluminum Foil and Pans

You can use aluminum foil and pans in a toaster oven, but make sure the foil doesn’t touch the heating elements.

Aluminum is a good conductor of heat and can be used for lining a baking tray or wrapping foods for easy cleanup. Just be cautious with the placement to avoid any potential fire hazards.

Parchment Paper and Paper Plates

Parchment paper or wax paper is an excellent alternative for lining baking trays; it’s safe and non-stick. It’s also great for wrapping food to avoid direct contact with the heating elements.

However, using paper plates, styrofoam plates, or cardboard plates in a toaster oven is not recommended, as they may not withstand high temperatures and could catch fire.

It is safest to avoid all paper plates no matter the types of paper plates offered. 


Silicone cookware is a popular choice due to its flexibility, non-stick properties, and resistance to high temperatures.

You can use silicone baking mats, molds, and utensils in a toaster oven without issue. Always check the manufacturer’s guidelines for temperature limits and safe usage.


Stoneware is a durable and versatile option for toaster ovens. It can handle high temperatures and retains heat well, making it suitable for cooking various dishes. 

Ensure your stoneware is marked as oven-safe before using it in a toaster oven. Avoid sudden changes in temperature, as it can cause damage or cracking.


Earthenware plates can be used in a toaster oven but be sure they’re labeled as oven-safe. While these plates can handle heat, they might crack if the toaster oven heats unevenly.

Keep an eye on the temperature and avoid exposing them to sudden changes in heat to prolong their lifespan.

With these options, you can efficiently utilize your toaster oven for various cooking tasks, as long as you adhere to safety guidelines and proper usage instructions.

Manufacturer Recommendations and Preheating

countertop toaster oven cooking food

Checking Manufacturer Guidelines

When using plates in your toaster oven, it’s crucial to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations. Prior to doing so, check if the manufacturers certify that their plates are oven-safe.

 Look for an oven-safe symbol or statement in the product’s user manual. Reading every single specification carefully before purchasing a set of plates is highly recommended.

Some materials, like plastic, should be avoided, as they can potentially start a fire.

Properly Preheating a Toaster Oven

Properly preheating your toaster oven ensures even cooking and reduces the risk of burning your food or damaging your plates.

This is a crucial step and unlike an air fryer that can be turned on and used right away, it may take some time for your toaster oven to heat up. 

The first thing before preheating your toaster oven, is to ensure there is not a food item or dish left inside, especially anything made from plastic or other heat-sensitive materials.

By preheating a toaster oven it will help to ensure better taste of your food. 

Here are the basic steps to preheat your toaster oven:

  1. Adjust the temperature settings to your desired level.
  2. Turn on the toaster oven and wait for the heating elements to reach the set temperature.
  3. When the preheat indicator light switches off or the toaster oven beeps, it’s ready for use.
  4. Place your oven-safe plate or tray inside, making sure it’s not too close to the heating elements, as the proximity can affect cooking results.

Take note that not all recipes require preheating. For some foods, such as pizza or cornbread, a hot tray is recommended for better outcomes.

However, for the majority of dishes, preheating the oven with a tray inside is not necessary. Most recipes offer cooking times to know how long  to leave food in the oven once preheating is completed.

Remember to always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines and verify whether a plate is suitable for use in a toaster oven.

It’s better to be cautious than to risk damage to your plates or toaster oven.

Toaster Oven Cooking Tips

silver countertop toaster oven with food in it

Adjusting Cooking Time

When using your toaster oven, it’s important to adjust your cooking time for best results. Cooking time can depend on how much food you are making, as well as what kind of food you are cooking.

Since toaster ovens are smaller and generally more energy efficient than traditional ovens, they may cook food faster.

Putting the oven on the highest or lowest temperature will also impact the amount of time it takes to finish cooking.

To ensure your meals are cooked properly, start by reducing the cooking time by approximately 25%. Keep an eye on your food and adjust the time accordingly.

Choosing the Right Foods

toaster oven with food in it in a kitchen

Selecting the appropriate foods to cook in a toaster oven is crucial for successful and safe cooking. Stick to items that can withstand high temperatures, such as oven-safe plates and dishes.

 As mentioned in Foods Guy and Kitchenaries, avoid using plates made of plastic, as they can melt and release toxic substances.

Also, make sure the manufacturer certifies that their plates are oven safe before using them in your toaster oven.

When it comes to the foods themselves, opt for recipes specifically designed for toaster oven cooking or pick dishes that can easily adapt to a smaller cooking space.

While the are not the only things, some examples include:

  • Small batches of baked goods
  • Toasted sandwiches
  • Casseroles
  • Roasted vegetables

Using Common Sense

Lastly, always apply common sense when using a toaster oven. Never leave it unattended while in use, and keep an oven mitt or towel handy to avoid burns. 

Make sure to place your toaster oven on a heat-resistant surface with ample space around it to prevent any potential hazards.

Additionally, give it time to cool down after usage before attempting to clean or move it.

By following these simple tips, you’ll enhance your toaster oven cooking experience while keeping safety in mind.

Tips to Remember

toaster oven with knobs

You can generally put a plate in a toaster oven or convection toaster oven, but it is crucial to ensure that the plate is oven-safe.

To determine if a plate is suitable for a toaster oven, pay close attention to the material it is made of and whether it is marked as oven-safe by the manufacturer.

A toaster oven is a small oven so it is important to factor in the size of a dish when purchasing based on toaster oven use. 

Plates made of ceramic, metal, or glass are typically oven-safe, but always verify before using them in a toaster oven.

When placing a plate in your toaster oven, take care to position it on the wire rack in the middle so it doesn’t touch the heating elements.

This is particularly important for glass or ceramic plates, as they could break if exposed to extreme heat.

Bear in mind that metal plates may cause sparks and start a fire if not properly used in a toaster oven.

Therefore, it’s crucial to follow manufacturer guidelines and exercise caution when introducing any cookware into your toaster oven.

By following these guidelines and ensuring you use oven-safe plates, you can confidently utilize your toaster oven for various cooking tasks while avoiding any risks or damages to your cookware.

Final Thoughts

single toaster oven on kitchen counter

When considering whether you can put a plate in a toaster oven, it is important to consider the different materials and guidelines provided in toaster oven manuals.

Toaster ovens typically use heating coils to cook and heat food efficiently.

While many plates can withstand the heat of a toaster oven, it is crucial to ensure that the plate is oven-safe and made of materials such as oven-safe glass or ceramic.

It is advisable to avoid using plates made of materials that may react poorly to high heat or that could potentially damage the heating elements of the toaster oven.

Additionally, considering the purpose of the toaster oven, such as reheating or cooking, can help determine if placing a plate in the toaster oven is necessary or if using alternative methods, such as silicone molds or oven-safe glass dishes, may be more suitable.

Utilizing a crumb tray or aluminium foil to catch any drips or crumbs can help keep the toaster oven clean.

By following the manufacturer’s instructions and considering the material and purpose, you can make informed decisions about using a plate in a toaster oven, ensuring the safety of the appliance and the integrity of the food being prepared.

can you put a plate in a toaster oven Pinterest image

Get the scoop on more like this: