Skip to Content

Pu Erh Tea Caffeine Vs Coffee: Benefits And Effects

Pu-Erh tea and coffee are two popular beverages that have earned reputations as morning staples for many people that help generate high energy levels. 

Both beverages contain caffeine, a natural stimulant often used to start the day and stay alert. 

However, the caffeine content in these two beverages varies, which can impact the overall experience for those looking to get a boost of energy or avoid the jitters.

pu erh tea caffeine vs coffee featuring a cup of coffee and a tray of tea with a blue tea kettle

Coffee is well known for having generally higher levels of caffeine.

The caffeine content of pu-erh tea can also serve as a great choice to provide a notable lift. 

A cup of coffee contains around 70 to 180 mg of caffeine, while an 8 oz cup of Pu-erh tea typically ranges from 30 to 70 mg of caffeine source

This difference in caffeine levels can make Pu-erh tea an appealing alternative for those seeking a less intense energy boost.

It’s also a great alternative for those looking to reduce their caffeine intake.

The processing and brewing methods for both Pu-erh tea and coffee play significant roles in determining the final caffeine content of each beverage source

As a result, consumers can find a wide range of caffeine levels within each category, allowing for personal preferences and individual tolerances to dictate the best choice. 

In addition to caffeine content, it’s essential to consider the taste, aroma, and other potential health benefits these beverages offer when making a choice.

Pu-Erh Tea Vs Coffee: Caffeine Content

Caffeine in Pu-Erh Tea

Pu-Erh tea, also referred to as pu’er tea, is a type of fermented tea that originates from China. 

The caffeine content of this chinese tea varies depending on factors such as processing, fermentation, and age. 

a glass kettle pouring hot tea into a glass tea cup

Research indicates that ripe pu-erh contains about 3.31% caffeine, while raw pu-erh has around 4.29% caffeine.

However, the overall caffeine content in pu-erh tea may also depend on serving size.

The serving size usually ranges between 50 and 95 mg for a regular 8 oz cup.

Some factors that influence the caffeine levels in pu-erh tea include:

  • Type of pu-erh: ripe or raw
  • Age of the tea leaf
  • Fermentation process

Caffeine in Coffee

Coffee is a beverage that you can make from roasted coffee beans and typically contains more caffeine than tea.

 The caffeine content in coffee beans can range from 1.1 to 2%, depending on factors such as the type of bean, roast level, and brewing method. 

A standard 8 oz cup of coffee usually contains between 50 and 95 mg of caffeine.

This amount can vary greatly depending on the specific coffee and preparation method.

Factors that influence caffeine content in coffee include:

  • Type of coffee bean
  • Roasting process
  • Brewing method
  • Serving size

When comparing the caffeine content of pu-erh tea and coffee, keep in mind that the specific amounts may vary depending on various factors. 

2 cups of coffee with late art with an additional beverage

While pu-erh tea generally has less caffeine than coffee, it still contains a significant amount of caffeine that can help increase alertness and energy. 

Pu-erh tea contains antioxidants, which help to shield your cells from the damages done by free radicals. 

Additionally, human studies have shown that pu’erh tea has additional benefits, such as decreasing the risk of heart disease, making it a potentially healthier option for those seeking a caffeinated beverage.

Effects of Caffeine from Pu-Erh Tea and Coffee

Mental Focus and Energy

Pu-Erh tea and coffee are both popular beverages known for their caffeine content which can help boost mental focus and energy. 

The caffeine content of Pu-Erh tea varies greatly depending on water temperature and steeping time. Raw Pu Erh tea contains caffeine between 70 and 80 mg per 8 oz cup (235 mL)

In contrast, an 8 oz cup of coffee typically has a high caffeine content of around 95 milligrams of caffeine.

The theanine, specifically L-theanine, present in Pu-Erh tea is known to promote relaxation while maintaining alertness. 

This unique combination of caffeine and L-theanine in Pu-Erh tea helps in improving cognitive function, mental focus, and providing a more stable energy boost compared to coffee.

Health Benefits and Risks

Pu-Erh tea is often consumed for its numerous health benefits, like improving mental alertness, reducing cholesterol levels, supporting one’s immune system, and even aiding in weight loss. 

You can use this tea type as traditional Chinese medicine, as it contains high amounts of amino acids and vitamin c. 

It is good to note that some of these claims may lack substantial scientific evidence to support them. 

People consume Pu-Erh tea for conditions such as high cholesterol, high blood pressure, obesity, diabetes, and many others, but there is no strong scientific evidence to support these uses.

On the other hand, scientific studies show that coffee provides certain health benefits.

These health benefits include reducing the risk of Parkinson’s disease, liver disease, and type 2 diabetes. 

However, excessive consumption of coffee can lead to heart problems, such as an increased risk of heart disease, and other health complications.

While Pu-Erh tea has lower caffeine content compared to coffee, consuming it in large quantities might cause unwanted side effects due to the caffeine content. 

These side effects can include headache, nervousness, sleep problems, vomiting, diarrhea, irritability, irregular heartbeat, tremor, heartburn, dizziness, ringing in the ears, convulsions, and confusion

However, drinking moderate amounts of Pu-Erh tea is less likely to cause such side effects in the human body.

In conclusion, both Pu-Erh tea and coffee can provide mental focus and energy boosts.

Pu-Erh tea offers a more stable energy experience due to the presence of the free amino acid, L-theanine. 

Health benefits and risks vary between the two beverages, and moderate consumption is advised to minimize adverse effects from their caffeine content.

Taste and Brewing Methods

a glass cup of tea with a tea bag and a glass cup of coffee with foam

Preparing Pu-Erh Tea

Pu-erh tea can have a wide range of flavors, from earthy and mellow to sweet and fruity aromas. 

The taste of this type of tea often depends on the specific type and age of the tea. 

To prepare pu-erh tea, it’s important to follow the proper brewing methods by keeping track of the brewing time and temperature.

To begin, preheat your teacup with hot water and then discard the water. 

Next, add 2 teaspoons (2g) of pu-erh tea leaves to the cup. 

Pour 8.8oz (250ml) of hot water (210°F/ 100°C) over the tea leaves and let them steep for 3-5 minutes before enjoying your tea. 

Pu-erh tea requires the water to be heated at higher temperatures compared to coffee, which is brewed in slightly cooler water. 

These instructions come from the BornTea Complete Guide to Pu-erh Tea.

An alternative method, called Gaiwan style, involves steeping the tea multiple times to achieve a range of flavors. 

You can learn more about this method from Perfect Brew’s guide.

Preparing Coffee

Coffee’s taste greatly depends on the type of coffee bean, roast, and brewing method used. 

Typically, coffee has a robust, rich, and sometimes bitter flavor, with varying levels of acidity and sweetness.

Cups of coffee that contain much caffeine will have a more intense and acidic flavor, compared to brews that use small amounts of caffeine.

In terms of brewing, one common method is using a drip coffee maker. 

For this, you would require a coffee filter, coffee grounds, and water. 

The brewing process involves adding the appropriate amount of coffee grounds to the filter, typically 1-2 tablespoons per 6oz of water. 

The water should be heated to around 195-205°F (90-96°C) source

Pour the hot water over the coffee grounds, allowing it to drip through the filter and into your cup.

Another popular method is the French Press. 

For this, you would need coarsely ground coffee and hot water. 

Add the coffee grounds to the French Press, followed by the hot water. 

Allow the coffee to steep for 4-5 minutes before pressing down the plunger and pouring your coffee.

Despite their differences in taste, temperature, brewing methods, steeping time, and beverage preparation, both pu-erh tea and coffee can be enjoyed based on personal preference.

Both offer unique flavors and experiences.

Types and Origins of Pu-Erh Tea and Coffee

Classification of Pu-Erh Tea

Pu-erh tea originates from the Yunnan Province of China.

Here it is made using the leaves of a special tea plant, different from those used for black, green, or white teas. 

Pu-erh tea contains leaves that come from the camellia sinensis plant, also known as camellia sinensis var. 

There are two main types of pu-erh tea, each with their unique processing methods:

  • Raw Pu-erh (Sheng): This tea undergoes natural fermentation with a gradual aging process, giving it a unique, complex flavor that improves over time as the tea ages, similar to fine wine. The raw pu-erh tea can be found in various forms of pu-erh tea extracts like loose leaves, cakes, bricks, and tea bags. In the early aging process, the taste of raw pu-erh tea is often compared to the flavor of green tea leaves, as it is earthy and woody.
  • Ripe Pu-erh (Shou): This type of pu-erh undergoes an accelerated fermentation process, to produce a richer, earthier tasting tea. The ripe pu-erh tea is often darker in color compared to raw pu-erh. This dark tea may also be available in different shapes such as cakes, bricks, and loose leaf tea. 

Apart from China, pu-erh tea is also grown and harvested in other Asian countries like Myanmar and Thailand.

Varieties of Coffee

Coffee is one of the world’s most popular beverages, consisting of roasted coffee beans, which come from the Coffea plant. 

There are two main types of coffee beans, along with several sub-varieties:

  • Arabica: This cultivar accounts for 60-70% of global coffee production, and is often known for its delicate, mild flavors and a pleasant acidity. Arabica beans are commonly grown in high altitude regions, with popular origins including Colombia, Brazil, and Ethiopia.
  • Robusta: The Robusta coffee bean has a stronger taste, higher caffeine content and is usually more affordable than Arabica coffee. Robusta plants are more resistant to pests and disease, making them easier to grow in lower altitude regions such as South Africa. You’ll often find Robusta beans in instant coffee, blended with Arabica for a more robust flavor.
  • Assam: this is a strong and rich variety, most popular in espresso-based drinks due to its bold flavors and thick creaminess.

Coffee can be consumed in various forms, such as brewed coffee, espresso, instant coffee or decaf coffee. 

The choice of method often affects the flavor and caffeine content of the final drink.

The characteristics of a coffee bean, including taste and aroma, are heavily influenced by the specific cultivar and the region of origin. 

This makes each coffee unique, just like the different types of tea, including pu-erh, black, green, white, and herbal teas. 

Fermentation and Oxidation in Pu-Erh Tea and Coffee

3 cups of coffee with intricate late art

Process of Fermentation in Pu-Erh Tea

Pu-Erh tea undergoes a unique fermentation process that contributes to its distinctive flavor profile. 

The process begins with the fully oxidized pu-erh leaves being placed in large piles. 

The microbial activity during the fermentation stage plays a significant role in shaping the tea’s taste and overall properties.

There are two types of Pu-Erh tea: raw and aged.

Raw Pu-Erh tea is the unfermented version.

Aged Pu Erh tea undergoes post-fermentation, a process involving the gradual oxidation and polymerization of flavan-3-ol by microorganisms.

The fermentation process in Pu-Erh tea involves:

  • Oxidation of tea leaves
  • Microbial fermentation with bacteria and fungi
  • Transformation of chemical compounds, such as the formation of theabrownin

Oxidation in Coffee

Unlike Pu-Erh tea, coffee does not undergo a fermentation process in the same sense. 

However, coffee beans do experience oxidation after being harvested, roasted, and ground. 

The oxidation in coffee beans is predominantly a chemical reaction, rather than a microbial one as seen in fermented teas like Pu-Erh.

During coffee processing and roasting, the beans undergo various levels of oxidation as follows:

  • Green coffee beans: minimal oxidation
  • Roasted coffee beans: increased oxidation due to exposure to heat and air
  • Ground coffee: rapid oxidation as a result of increased surface area

It is important to note that while both Pu-Erh tea and coffee undergo oxidation, the processes differ in significant ways. 

This is an important factor to consider when it comes to pu erh tea caffeine vs coffee.

This, in turn, may affect your view of whether coffee or pu-erh tea is the better option for you. 

In Pu-Erh tea, oxidation contributes to further fermentation, while in coffee, it mainly affects aroma, flavor, and freshness. 

Furthermore, coffee does not have the same microbial activity that gives fermented teas like Pu-Erh their distinct characteristics.

To summarize, the fermentation process in Pu-Erh tea involves microbial activity and the transformation of chemical compounds.

This process contributes to its unique taste and properties, such as its earthy flavor. 

On the other hand, coffee experiences oxidation on a chemical level.

This affects aspects like aroma and flavor rather than undergoing a similar fermentation process as seen in tea.

Health Benefits of Pu Erh Tea and Coffee

a floral cup of tea on with a tea spoon

Weight Loss and Metabolism

Pu-Erh tea is believed to help with losing excess body weight or fat.

It does this by increasing the amount of dietary-fat-bound bile acid excreted in feces, thus preventing the fat from being absorbed into the bloodstream (source). 

Additionally, coffee is known to boost metabolism, which can contribute to weight loss. 

This can be an important factor when considering pu erh tea caffeine vs coffee.

Both beverages contain caffeine, which stimulates the central nervous system, and can increase fat burning by increasing energy expenditure.

If you’ve been looking for a healthy diet to help you lose weight, try drinking either coffee or pu-erh tea.  

Digestion and Gut Health

In the world of tea, Pu-Erh tea has been reported to improve digestive health and relieve constipation, owing to its ability to encourage bowel movements (source). 

Similarly, coffee is known to promote gut motility and help with digestion. 

Both Pu-Erh tea and coffee contain antioxidants that promote a healthy gut environment by reducing inflammation and supporting the growth of beneficial gut bacteria.

Antioxidants and Other Nutrients

Both Pu-Erh tea and coffee are rich in antioxidants.

These antioxidants can help protect cells from damage and reduce the risk of chronic diseases. 

They contain polyphenols, which are micronutrients with antioxidant properties.

These have potential health benefits related to reducing inflammation and improving heart health. 

Pu-Erh tea is said to have additional benefits such as decreasing the risk of heart disease (source).

Coffee contains antioxidants such as chlorogenic acid, which may help to lower blood pressure and protect against heart disease.

However, it’s important to note that excessive consumption of coffee can potentially lead to headaches, migraines, and increased cholesterol levels. 

It is important to consume both beverages in moderation.

Considering their potential side effects and the varying caffeine content between the two: raw Pu-Erh tea contains between 70 and 80 mg of caffeine per 8 oz cup.

A standard cup of coffee may contain 95 mg (source).

In summary, both Pu-Erh tea and coffee offer a range of health benefits, including weight loss, improved digestion, and a wealth of antioxidants. 

When it comes to pu erh tea caffeine vs coffee, both of these beverages have antioxidants and other nutrients.

It is essential to remain mindful of their caffeine content and consume them responsibly to avoid potential side effects. 

As always, it is important to maintain a balanced diet and consult with a healthcare professional before introducing any new health remedies.

Additional Considerations

a clear cup of coffee on a plate next to a cup of tea

Caffeine Safety and Dependency

While both pu erh tea and coffee contain caffeine, it’s essential to monitor your intake, since excessive caffeine consumption may lead to dependence and adverse health effects. 

This is important to consider when deciding between pu erh tea caffeine vs coffee intake.

According to the USDA, a safe caffeine intake is up to 400 mg per day for healthy adults.

Caffeine is a natural stimulant found in varying amounts in tea leaves like Camellia sinensis and coffee beans.

Caffeine is also in other beverages like espresso, yerba mate, and cold brew. 

Moderate caffeine consumption can provide an energy boost and enhance alertness. 

Nevertheless, excessive intake may cause negative effects consisting of overdose symptoms such as anxiety, insomnia, and increased heart rate.

It’s worth noting that the caffeine content in various beverages can significantly vary. 

For example, a double shot of espresso may have a higher concentration of caffeine than a serving of cold brew tea or matcha tea.

As well as this, there are also certain people, such as pregnant women, that need to consider whether it is safe to consume caffeine at all depending on their condition. 

Alternatives to Caffeine-Containing Beverages

If you’re looking for alternatives to caffeine-containing beverages, there are several options to consider. 

Some caffeine-free options for individuals concerned about dependence or caffeine safety include:

  • Herbal teas: These herbal infusions are made from plants other than Camellia sinensis, such as chamomile, which naturally does not contain caffeine. Use a large teapot to brew these delicious caffeine-free teas.
  • Decaffeinated coffee: This is coffee with most of its caffeine content removed, offering a similar flavor to regular coffee without the stimulant effect.
  • Cold brew tea: Cold brew tea typically has a lower caffeine content than hot tea, providing a milder energy boost. Whether you like the mild woody flavor of oolong tea, the sweet and floral taste of white tea, or the smoky and intense notes present in black tea, it’s always a good idea to go brew yourself a cold cup of tea. 
a cup of coffee and a cup of tea by a plate of cookies

Coffee drinkers and tea drinkers alike will be happy to hear that both pu-erh tea and coffee offer unique taste profiles, caffeine content, and health benefits. 

However, it’s crucial to consider the potential risks and alternatives when choosing the best beverage for your needs.

Knowing all of the health benefits and effect is important when considering pu erh tea caffeine vs coffee.

By staying informed, you can maintain a healthier and more balanced lifestyle.

pu erh tea caffeine vs coffee benefits and effects featuring a cup of tea and coffee

Get the scoop on more like this: