Can You Put Uncrustables In The Toaster Or Air Fryer?

Have you ever wondered if you can put Uncrustables sandwiches in the toaster?

toaster and uncrustable sandwich box

It’s a common question that arises for those who enjoy this frozen item that is crust-free with peanut butter and jelly filling. 

Smucker’s Uncrustables are a frozen sandwich that can be found at your local grocery stores in the freezer aisle and freezer section.

Worry not, because we’ll explore this very topic and provide a direct answer when applicable.

Toasting a frozen Uncrustable sandwich is the best way because it can have its benefits, such as giving the sandwich a slightly crispier crust, which adds a delightful texture that some people enjoy. 

However, there are some main reasons and precautions you’ll need to consider before popping Uncrustable sandwiches into your toaster. 

So, let’s dive into the details and find out if toasting the original Uncrustables is a viable option for your snack cravings.

Basics of Uncrustables

uncrustables in toaster with box

What Are Uncrustables

Uncrustables are pre-made peanut butter and jelly, crustless sandwiches produced by Smucker’s. 

They come individually packaged and are the best option for school lunches, a quick lunch, and an easy snack.

The most popular varieties of Uncrustables contain peanut butter and jelly fillings, but there are some options that feature other ingredients, like cheese sandwiches. 

The easy way is to simply thaw, and they’re ready to eat. But if you’re wondering if you can put Uncrustables in the toaster, the answer is yes. 

Toasting your Uncrustable with the toaster method is a sure sign that can give the sandwich a slightly crispier crust for those who enjoy a different texture.

Common Types and Flavors

Uncrustables come in different flavors, including:

  • Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly: The classic Peanut butter & jelly combination, featuring Smucker’s grape jelly and creamy peanut butter on white bread.
  • Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam: This option contains Smucker’s strawberry jam and gooey peanut butter on white bread.
  • Peanut Butter & Raspberry Spread: A twist on the classic, with raspberry spread and creamy peanut butter on white bread.
  • Turkey & Colby-Jack: A savory option, this Uncrustable contains deli-style turkey, Colby-Jack cheese, and a touch of mustard on whole wheat bread.
  • Uncrustables Bites: Smaller, bite-sized versions that come in various flavors such as Chocolate Hazelnut, BBQ Chicken, and Taco Bites.
  • Cheese Uncrustables
  • French Toast Uncrustables
  • Ice Cream Sandwich Uncrustables

With a variety of options, Uncrustables are a great way to cater towards everyone’s taste. 

Remember, if you want to store your Uncrustable in the refrigerator, it’s a good idea to eat them within 24 hours, but for the best flavor, you should consume them within 8-10 hours of thawing. 

Next time, enjoy your Uncrustable whether you prefer it toasted or thawed.

Heating Uncrustables

holding uncrustable sandwich

Do’s and Don’ts

When heating or cooking Uncrustables using the most popular method of toasting, there are a few guidelines to follow:

  • Do: Remove the Uncrustable from its wrapper before microwaving or toasting.
  • Do: Allow the Uncrustable to thaw for 30-60 minutes before placing it in the toaster. Your body heat could speed up the thawing process
  • Do: your best bet is to use only one Uncrustable at a time for heating, as heating multiple sandwiches may cause them to stick together.
  • Don’t: Microwave your Uncrustable for too long – this can cause it to become too hard to eat. Only heat for 15-20 seconds
  • Don’t: Set your toaster settings too high, as this can cause burning.

Toasting in Oven and Toaster Oven

uncrustable sandwiches in packages near toaster

You can also heat your Uncrustables in an oven or toaster oven for a slightly crispier crust. Follow these steps for a warm, gooey sandwich:

  1. Preheat your oven or toaster oven to 350°F (175°C).
  2. Place the thawed Uncrustable on a baking sheet, and bake for 5-7 minutes, keeping a close eye to avoid burning.
  3. The last thing is to remove the Uncrustable from the oven when it’s heated through and slightly crispy.

Alternative methods to consider

While toasters, ovens, and toaster ovens are popular choices for heating Uncrustables, there are other methods you may want to explore:

  • Air Fryer Uncrustables: Preheat the air fryer basket to 350°F (175°C), and cook the thawed Uncrustable for 3-5 minutes or until it reaches your desired crispiness.
  • Heating Pad: You can also use a heating pad set on low to gently warm and defrost an Uncrustable. Place the wrapped sandwich on the heating pad for 10-15 minutes or until it reaches room temperature.
  • Thawing: It’s perfectly fine to enjoy your Uncrustable at room temperature. Simply allow it to defrost for about 30 minutes before consuming.

Remember to keep an eye on the heating process and adjust the time as needed to achieve the perfect texture and taste for your Uncrustable. Enjoy your warm and delicious sandwich!

Making Uncrustables Crispy

uncrustable sandwiches sticking out of toaster

Alternative Methods to Toasting

Even though you can put Uncrustables in the toaster, there are other methods that can provide a crispy and warm effect. 

Instead of using a toaster, you can consider using a skillet, grill, or stovetop to heat your Uncrustables. 

Each method has its own advantages and can result in slightly different textures and tastes.

  • Skillet: To use a skillet, simply heat a non-stick pan over medium heat. Place your Uncrustable in the skillet and cook for 1-2 minutes on each side, or until golden brown and crispy.
  • Grill: For a grilled Uncrustable, heat your grill to a medium setting. Place the sandwich on the grill, close the lid, and cook for 2-3 minutes. Flip the sandwich and cook for another 2-3 minutes until both sides are crispy.
  • Stovetop: A stovetop griddle or large frying pan can also be used. Heat your pan over medium heat, and cook your Uncrustable on each side for 1-2 minutes or until desired crispiness is achieved.

Using Oil or Butter

In each of the alternative methods mentioned above, you can enhance the flavor and crispiness of your Uncrustable by using some butter or oil.

Just a small amount can make a great addition and big difference in taste.

  • For the skillet or stovetop methods, spread a thin layer of butter or oil on each side of the Uncrustable before placing it in the pan. This will give an extra crispy texture to the sandwich, while also adding a hint of buttery flavor.
  • When using a grill, brush a light layer of oil onto the grates before placing your sandwich on the grill. This will prevent the sandwich from sticking and make it easier to achieve a crispy, golden-brown exterior.

Remember that using butter or oil is optional, but it can definitely enhance the final result by providing a crispy and warm texture to your Uncrustable. 

Don’t shy away from experimenting with these methods to find the one that suits your preferences best.

Safety Reasons

sandwiches sticking out of toaster

Uncrustables and Allergens

Before enjoying your Uncrustables, you should be aware of potential allergens in the products. 

The most common allergen in peanuts, as many Uncrustables contain peanut butter. 

Additionally, some Uncrustables may contain other allergens such as tree nuts, soy, and wheat. 

Make sure to check the packaging for allergen information before consuming an Uncrustable. 

If you have a severe allergy, be especially careful when toasting a warm Uncrustable to avoid cross-contamination with other allergens in your toaster.

Some other ingredients that could affect an individual negatively are citric acid and soy lecthin.

Proper Handling and Storage

To ensure your Uncrustables are safe and enjoyable to eat, follow proper handling and storage guidelines. 

Uncrustables should be kept in the freezer until you’re ready to thaw them. 

How long do Uncrustables last in the freezer?

Uncrustables can last a long time when stored in a freezer for up to 3 months. They should be stored in an airtight container.

Make sure that ice crystals or freezer burns have not formed on your sandwiches before consuming them.

Thaw at room temperature for 30 to 60 minutes for the best results and consume within 8 to 10 hours. Never thaw using warm water.

Don’t microwave Uncrustables, as the filling can become very hot and pose a safety hazard.


view of a toaster with uncrustable sandwich inside

When toasting your thawed Uncrustables, monitor the toasting process carefully to avoid burning or uneven heating. 

It’s advised to use a toaster or toaster oven for about 3-4 minutes while monitoring. 

If you’re using a stovetop, do so with caution and ensure the sandwich is heated evenly.

Aluminum foil can be used to speed up the heating process when placing the sandwich in an oven.

Avoid storing Uncrustables in the refrigerator, as this can cause the bread to become soggy. 

Instead, continue to store remaining Uncrustables in their original packaging in the freezer until you’re ready to thaw and eat them. 

Keep in mind the expiration date of the manufacturer’s recommendation, to ensure that you consume your Uncrustable on time.

If your Uncrustables come wrapped in plastic wrap or other packaging, be sure to remove it before toasting.

Be mindful of the ingredients in Uncrustables, such as sugar, high fructose corn syrup, and vegetable oil, if you’re following a specific diet or have dietary concerns. 

While some Uncrustables may contain these ingredients, it’s essential to check packaging for complete ingredient lists and nutritional information.

Additionally, remember that unrefrigerated Uncrustables are not advised to consume after 2 hours. An ice pack could help to preserve the sandwich for a longer period of time.

Creative Ways to Enjoy Uncrustables

strawberry uncrustable sandwiches on a plate

Recipe Ideas

Uncrustables are a convenient and delicious treat that can be enjoyed as a quick snack or as part of a meal. 

While they taste great right out of the package, you can also get creative and try different ways to prepare your Uncrustables.

Consider these unique ideas for your next snacking adventure:

  • Toasted Uncrustables: Though typically a frozen, crustless jelly sandwich, placing an Uncrustable in the toaster can create a delightfully crispy crust. Simply remove the packaging, set your toaster on a low setting, and toast for 1-2 minutes or until the desired crispiness is achieved. Take out the toasted uncrustable and place on a paper towel.
  • Waffle-style Uncrustables: For a new twist, dip your Uncrustable in a waffle batter with a little bit of vanilla added. Pan-fry or deep-fry the dipped sandwich until golden brown. Please note that air fryers may not handle this type of wet batter well.
  • Microwaved Uncrustables: To enjoy a warm and soft sandwich, you can microwave an Uncrustable by first removing it from the wrapper and heating it for a short period. Be sure to only heat one sandwich at a time.
  • Easy Air Fryer Recipes: A crispy treat can be achieved by using the air fryer method. Place your Uncrustable in an air fryer and heat it to your desired crispness level.

Different Types of Sandwiches

close up of uncrustable sandwiches on a plate

Uncrustables come in a variety of fillings and bread options, allowing you to enjoy different combinations that cater to your preferences. Some common variations include:

  • Classic PB&J: This classic peanut butter and jelly uncrustable features regular peanut butter and jelly on either white or whole wheat bread. PB & J sandwich is another name for this flavor with a gooey filling.
  • Alternative Fillings: If you’re looking to switch things up, try Uncrustables with different fillings, such as hazelnut spread, honey, or even chocolate.
  • Own Homemade Uncrustables: For a personalized touch, make your own Uncrustables using your favorite combination of bread, fillings, and even add butter to the bread before sealing the edges for extra flavor. A common recipe includes the use of a single layer of natural peanut butter, slices of bread, whole-wheat bread or white bread, and a sandwich sealer or a stainless steel cookie cutter.

Remember, whether you’re on-the-go or looking for a satisfying snack at home, Uncrustables offer a variety of options to suit your taste buds. 

Enhance your snacking experience by using these tricks and exploring creative ways to enjoy your favorite jelly sandwich.

Final Thoughts

half eaten uncrustable sandwich on plate

While there may be a TikTok video showcasing toasting Uncrustables, it is important to follow specific instructions.

Uncrustables are pre-made peanut butter and jelly sandwiches that are typically enjoyed without toasting.

The composition of Uncrustables includes ingredients like jelly and soy lecithin that may not respond well to the high heat of a toaster.

Moreover, the use of stainless steel cookie cutters to trim the crusts off Uncrustables can pose a safety hazard if placed directly in a toaster.

It is advisable to follow the intended instructions for consuming Uncrustables, which involve enjoying them straight from the package.

By adhering to these guidelines, you can savor the convenience and flavors of Uncrustables without compromising safety or the integrity of the product.

can you put uncrustables in the toaster Pinterest image

Get the scoop on more like this:

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *