Can You Put Brownies Back In The Oven Undercooked

Have you ever wondered if you can put brownies back in the oven?

Picture this scenario: You’ve just baked a batch of delicious, warm brownies with deep chocolate flavor, only to discover that they’re undercooked after taking them out of the oven.

brownies stacked on top of one another with white background

Even though they spend the appropriate amount of time baking. 

Now you’re stuck with a batch of brownies that might still have raw batter in them, and you’ll have to try again next time. 

Don’t panic, though – this isn’t a lost cause. 

The good thing is that there are several easy ways to determine if these gooey brownies actually contain raw brownie batter in the center of the brownies. 

In fact, it’s a common mistake many home bakers face, even with store-bought brownies, and there are solutions to ensure that your brownies achieve the perfect texture and doneness like a toasted slice of bread.

There are a few different ways to know if the kind of brownies you made should have a gooey center of it the cakey texture is really a result of an undercooked brownie. 

The main question is: can you put raw brownies back in the oven if they’re undercooked?

Can you adjust the oven heat to the right temperature and resume the cooking process for just a little bit longer? 

The short answer is yes, you can, but there are some considerations you need to keep in mind to avoid overcooking or drying out your brownies. 

It’s good to have crisp outer edges and a crust on the top of the brownies, but a good indication that your fresh brownies have gone hard after baking them longer is when the edges of the brownies are rock hard and you can’t test the center of your brownies. 

We’ve got the scoop on how you can rescue your undercooked brownies with different techniques and give you the tools to confidently handle this baking challenge.

With these effective methods for crafting the perfect fluffy brownies, you’ll be on your way to creating moist brownies with the best results and a delicious treat every single time. 

Recognizing Undercooked Brownies

close up of chocolate brownies

Toothpick Test

One of the easiest ways to determine if your brownies are not done is by using the toothpick test in the middle of the brownies. 

Simply insert a toothpick or bamboo skewers into the center of the brownies. If it comes out with gooey, uncooked batter, you know they need more time in the oven. 

It’s good to have some gooey texture. But gooey brownie residue is a sign that the dairy products and raw eggs inside are still baking. 

A perfect brownie, however, will result in a toothpick that has some moist crumbs attached. Indicating that the center is cooked, but still moist and fudgy.

It’s also a good way to determine if you need to cook your brownies at higher temperatures. Even if it might go over the recommended baking time. 

Edges and Center

half eaten brownie and crumbs

It’s important to also pay attention to the edges and center of the brownie when looking for signs of undercooking. 

The best brownies have a crisp edge around the sides of the pan. The top of your brownies should also have a crispness to them. 

The edges should be fully set and slightly crispy, while the center of the warm brownie should be moist and fudgy, but not liquidy. 

Observing the consistency of the brownie through these visual cues is a great way to determine whether it needs more cooking time. 

Your personal preference might be to have chewy brownies or hard brownies. But it’s a good idea to determine if your brownies are safe to eat.  

Remember that the center will continue to cook as the brownies cool, so avoid overcooking the edges and creating dry brownies to get a perfectly cooked center.

Fudgy vs. Cakey

The preferred texture of brownies can vary: some people prefer a fudgier, chewier brownie. While others opt for a cakier, fluffier texture. 

The good news is that you can suit your brownies to fit your own preferences, but this can impact how you recognize undercooked brownies.

For a fudgy brownie, a moist crumb on the toothpick is ideal. 

These types of brownies leave less left over because of their consistency. 

In contrast, a cakey brownie may require a cleaner toothpick

However, in both cases, it’s essential to find a balance and avoid overly gooey centers that indicate undercooking. 

Uncooked brownies can indicate E. coli at worst, making it unsafe to consume. 

By understanding your recipe’s intended outcome, you’ll better determine if your brownies are perfection or need more time in the oven.

Putting Brownies Back in the Oven

chocolate brownies cut up in pan

Temperature and Time Adjustments

When you have undercooked brownies, it is possible to put them back in the oven for further cooking. 

To do this, preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit (or lower the temperature by 25 degrees Fahrenheit if you already removed the brownies).

Place the brownies back in their baking tray or on a regular baking tray with parchment paper or wax paper if you have already removed them from the original one.

If you still have your brownies in a glass pan, return the glass pan to the oven. 

As a general guideline, bake the brownies for an additional 2 minutes and then check their doneness using the toothpick method. 

If they are still gooey inside, continue baking and checking every 2 minutes until they reach the desired consistency.

Monitoring the Doneness

plain brownies on parchment paper

To accurately determine if your brownies are done, use the toothpick test. 

Insert a toothpick into the center of the brownie tray, and if it comes out clean or with a few moist crumbs, the brownies are perfect. 

If the toothpick comes out coated with batter, they need more time in the oven.

It’s essential to keep an eye on your brownies to avoid overcooking them. Which can result in dry and tough brownies.

The global director of food, Katzie Guy-Hamilton examines them when the brownies first start to crack at the top.

Check them every 3-5 minutes while they’re back in the oven, even if this goes over the recommended cooking times.  

By following these tips, you can rescue your undercooked brownies and achieve the perfect doneness.

Additionally, know that you can save your leftover brownies for the next day when they’re crisp to perfection. 

Simply place your cool brownies in aluminum foil or plastic wrap or in an airtight container and store them away. 

Brownies typically have a long shelf life no matter the type of brownies you baked. 

Fixing Undercooked Brownies

chocolate brownies on plate cut up

Fixing Undercooked Brownies in the Oven

To fix undercooked brownies, simply put them back in a preheated 350°F oven and continue baking. 

Check for doneness using the toothpick test. Atoothpick inserted into the brownie should come out with only a few bits of brownie attached. 

This method works best if you catch the problem soon after removing the brownies from the oven.

Alternative Methods

If putting the brownies back in the oven isn’t an option, you can try the following simple ways:

  1. Microwave: Microwave individual slices of brownie for a few seconds to firm them up. You can place them in a microwave-safe container if necessary.
  2. Refrigerate: Place the brownies in the fridge to set them further. This helps for fudgy brownies that are slightly undercooked but have been removed from the baking tray.

Addressing Overcooking Issues

cut up brownies stacked on top of one another on a plate

When fixing undercooked brownies, it’s crucial to avoid overcooking. 

While you need to use room temperature ingredients, brownies require a high temperature that can cause overcooking if you’re not careful. 

Overcooked brownies become dry and lose their fudgy texture. Here are some tips to prevent overcooking:

  • Monitor the internal temperature of the brownies, ensuring they reach around 200°F.
  • When placing brownies back in the oven, check for doneness every 2 minutes.
  • Use a timer to keep track of the baking time.

Remember, the quality of the brownie mix, as well as the ratio of ingredients like flour and butter, can impact the final texture of the brownies.

Achieving Perfect Brownies

close up of stacked brownies

Importance of Oven Temperature

A consistent oven temperature is one of many good reasons to creating flawless brownies. 

It’s advisable to invest in an oven thermometer that accurately measures the internal temperature. Ensuring that your baked treats are cooked evenly. 

When the temperature fluctuates, the texture of the brownies can be negatively impacted and leave room for bacteria like E. coli to grow. 

Generally, the ideal temperature for baking brownies is around 350 degrees Fahrenheit. 

This also may need to be adjusted depending on the size of the pan, or if you’re using other tools such as an air fryer

Balancing Ingredients and Mixing

stacked brownies with blue background

To achieve the perfect balance between fudge brownies and cake-like brownies, carefully measure ingredients according to your brownie recipes

It’s important not to overmix the batter, as this can lead to cakey brownies. 

The best way is to use a whisk or a spatula to gently combine the ingredients until they’re just incorporated. 

If you’re adding nuts or other mixins, fold them in last, to maintain the desired texture.

Baking Sheet and Pan Choices

The type of baking sheet and pan you choose can significantly affect the outcome of your brownies. 

A metal pan is great for even heat distribution, resulting in well-baked treats. 

Be sure to select the pan size specified in your recipe to achieve the ideal thickness and baking time.

When checking for doneness, use a cake tester or skewer to probe the center of the brownies. 

If it comes out with a few moist crumbs, your brownies are good. 

Avoid overbaking, as this can lead to dry, cakey brownies. 

If your brownies seem undercooked, you can put them back in the oven for a few minutes, while carefully monitoring them to ensure they don’t become dry or burnt.

After removing the brownies from the oven, allow them to cool on a wire rack. 

To expedite the cooling process, you can place the pan in the freezer for a short period. 

Proper cooling is essential for achieving the desired texture and taste of your brownies.

After all that work, you deserve to enjoy your brownies!

Top your treats off if ice cream or some chocolate chips and dig in!

Final Thoughts

cut up brownie on utensil

If you find that your brownies are undercooked, it is possible to put them back in the oven for further baking.

By returning the undercooked brownies to the oven, you can give them additional time to set and achieve a more desirable texture.

However, it’s important to monitor the brownies closely to prevent overbaking and drying them out. It’s recommended to check for doneness by inserting a toothpick into the center of the brownies.

If it comes out with a few moist crumbs clinging to it, the brownies are done. Remember to consider the specific recipe and baking instructions to ensure the best results.

With a little extra time and attention, you can salvage your undercooked brownies and achieve a deliciously moist and fully cooked treat.

can you put brownies back in the oven Pinterest image

Get the scoop on more like this:

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *